Hard would you rather questions
Most would you rather lists are about eating something disgusting. They're funny, but they're over in seconds because the answer doesn't tell you anything.
These are harder because either choice costs you something. Your answer says what you actually value, and the argument afterward is the point of the game.
Three questions to start with
Be deeply loved by a few, or liked by everyone?
- Loved by a few
- Liked by everyone
Relive your best year, or skip your worst one?
- Relive the best
- Skip the worst
Know exactly what people think of you, or never know?
- Always know
- Never know
Get all 20 cards in Would You Rather
The Why turns these into a swipeable deck that gets deeper as you go. No account needed. For adults 18+.
The only follow-up you need
The pick matters less than the reason. Every time someone chooses, ask "why that one?" and don't accept "it just is". A person choosing to relive their best year and a person choosing to skip their worst are saying very different things about how they see their past.
Ways to play
- Guess first: predict what the other person will choose, then see how well you know them.
- No fence-sitting: you have to choose an option as written, without adding conditions.
- Road trip rule: whoever loses the vote picks the next question.
Common questions
What makes a would you rather question hard?
Both options have to be appealing or both have to hurt, so there's no obvious answer. The hardest ones set two things you value against each other, like time and money.
Are these suitable for a party?
Yes. They're quick to answer and easy to argue about, and everyone can play without sharing anything too personal.